기본 콘텐츠로 건너뛰기

Cat Person, By Kristen Roupenian (2017)

Cat Person, By Kristen Roupenian (2017)

Rating: 8.5/10

Reading my first Roupenian story, one thing I realized was that Kristen Roupenian shares a similar writing style with Shirley Jackson. The simplistic and clear plot that both authors show as they unfold the story's message. They both develop the story in a very short scene of life with a minimum amount of characters. I personally thought this style of writing shown in <Cat Person> was the reason why many men hated this story. There are both pros and cons of this style, the pros are that it delivers the message to the audience very directly, but the cons are that it's too delivered too simply and without any deeper explanation that audiences can also misinterpret the message. For this case, it only reflected Margot's point of view that male readers misunderstood the message as if Roupenian is trying to criticize males, that in the end, Roupenian only seems as trying to induce social conflicts. As I said, this story had pros and cons, the point it emphasized was necessary for our society, but we need to be aware of the fact that we can cause another problem even if we were trying to solve one in the first place.


댓글

이 블로그의 인기 게시물

The Swimmer, By John Cheever (1964)

The Swimmer, By John Cheever (1964) Rating: 9.3/10 I personally think these kinds of stories are what short stories should be like. Very easy to understand, direct, and clear, but also a very unusual way of unfolding the plot compared to other stories. The main character was similar to Blake from The Five-Forty-Eight, they both represent American white men during the era. The devices like alcohol, pool, and season were implemented in a very enjoyable way so that readers can follow them like a clue and reach the conclusion. What I notice from recent stories we've read is that we don't whether the main character changes or not, it's always an open ending, however, we see their environment changing as a consequence of their prior actions. Overall very amusing and I wished I had the ability to write stories like this that can closely touch the readers.

James Joyce vs Anton Chekhov

James Joyce vs Anton Chekhov First, I would like to define the characteristics of each author, starting with James Joyce. Based on Joyce's stories I've read so far, I felt that his stories are very concise and efficient. And he also manages well to use the advantage of writing a short story and maximize it. Instead, Chekhov focuses on the change of the character's mindset which is also emphasized by the same daily routine that is described differently from each perspective, before the change, during the change, and after the change. Both authors end the story with an open conclusion, but I found Chekhov's conclusion more intriguing to read. In the story <The Lady with the Dog>, Chekhov doesn't imply any ethical messages or moral lessons in his conclusion. For example, writers like Tolstoy would end the conclusion of wrongdoers with punishment, but in this story, Gurov and Anna don't pay anything for committing adultery, leaving the readers to decide. Overa...

The Lady with the Dog, By Anton Chekhov (1899)

The Lady with the Dog, By Anton Chekhov (1899) Rating: 6.5/10 I didn't really enjoy this story as much as other short stories. The reason why is because, throughout the whole story, there were unnecessary rhetorical devices that were repetitive. For example, the author describes the place 'Yalta' not only at the opening but kept mentioning it whenever Gurov and Anna would take a walk. For me, this style of writing distanced me, the reader from the flow of the theme that this story is trying to deliver. It did enhance the reader's understanding of each individual character's change of thoughts, but interpreting the theme, wasn't efficient. At least the story ended with a totally open conclusion, but I would've enjoyed it much better if the story gave more space to the readers also during the process of reaching the conclusion.